Looking at the ratings a little more closely, I think A.P. Hill deserves a bit of a bump as a division commander.
Take a look at his performance:
Seven Days Battles: A bit of a mixed performance, but that was on par with most of Lee's commanders during this period (Jackson was uncharacteristically poor during these fights). A.P. Hill went in unsupported, and got his men chewed up at Mechanicsville (Jackson was late), but otherwise seems to have performed pretty well.
2nd Bull Run: Hill performed VERY well during this battle, holding the Rebel left flank against overwhelming odds.
Antietam: As I mentioned in my previous post, after a tough march that saw many of his men fall out from exhaustion, Hill arrived in time from Harpers Ferry to save the day.
Fredricksburg: This was not A.P. Hill's best day...he left a hole in his defensive lines that was punctured by a Federal assault.
Chancellorsville: His division took part in Jackson's famous flank attack
Here is a quote from the wikipedia link below:
Nevertheless, Hill was one of the war's most highly regarded generals on either side. When Hill was a major general, Robert E. Lee wrote that he was the best at that grade in the Army. He had a reputation for arriving on battlefields (such as Antietam, Cedar Mountain, and Second Bull Run) just in time to prove decisive and achieve victory. Stonewall Jackson on his deathbed deliriously called for A. P. Hill to "prepare for action"; some histories have recorded that Lee also called for Hill in his final moments ("Tell Hill he must come up."), although current medical opinions believe that Lee was unable to speak during his last illness.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A.P._Hill
Both 1's for Offensive and Defensive seem a bit low to me.
I would recommend the following settings:
157 CSA Ambrose P. Hill ldr_CSA_APHill2 NULL NULL NULL NULL 6 5 2 14 General 1 NULL 5 2 2
193 CSA Ambrose P. Hill ldr_CSA_APHill Fast_Move NULL NULL NULL 1 1 1 20 General 1 NULL 5 3 3