John A. Logan

[rickd79]

John A. Logan:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_A._Logan

277 USA John A. Logan ldr_USA_Logan2 NULL NULL NULL NULL 8 10 2 22 General 1 NULL 4 4 4
302 USA John A. Logan ldr_USA_Logan NULL NULL NULL NULL 8 10 1 13 General 1 NULL 4 4 4

1. Nickname: "Black Jack"

2. Is Logan overrated a little bit? (Keep in mind, Stonewall Jackson is currently rated at 5/4/4...Logan is at 4/4/4. Logan was certainly good (he won the medal of honor for the Vicksburg Campaign). However, I'd be very interested to see where other people think he stacks up in comparison to some of the other, more well known Civil War generals.

My suggestion:
4/3/2

[rickd79]

If the AGEOD folks feel like it, an Army-command entry can also be added for Logan. He commanded the Federal Army of the Tennessee for a while after McPherson was killed.

[Chris0827]

He was probably the best of the Union's political generals. 4|3|3 would make him slightly better than Sickles.

[Korrigan]

USA John A. Logan ldr_USA_Logan3 NULL NULL NULL NULL 8 10 3 22 General 1 NULL 4 3 3 Black Jack
277 USA John A. Logan ldr_USA_Logan2 NULL NULL NULL NULL 8 10 2 22 General 1 NULL 4 3 3 Black Jack
302 USA John A. Logan ldr_USA_Logan NULL NULL NULL NULL 8 10 1 13 General 1 NULL 3 2 2 Black Jack