Seniority gain/loss bug?

[bob.]

Is this WAD or a bug?

Roman general losing 2 battles in succession:


Yet this consul is now at 1 seniority! He actually gained seniority from these battles?!? At the same time the Carthaginian general loses seniority for battles that he wins. How can this be?

[Soderini]

AFAIK, commanders gain seniority based on their performance in battle, not based on wether they win or lose a battle. Since the Carthaginians lost more elements than the Romans I think Valerius is considered to have excelled in commanding his outnumbered forces against a superior enmy, while Hanno on the other hand is blamed for it.

[bob.]

Hm, I understand. I considered this already, but then I think this should be reworked a bit. The problem is that in the BOR scenarios where it's always Romans vs non-Romans and never equal forces, usually the Roman troops are vastly better compared to their size. This means that the Romans pretty much always gain seniority.