OneArmedMexican wrote:One thing that seems out of proportion is the number of leaders that die in this game.
Clovis, I know that you already told me that you might consider lowering the leader death probability slightly and I appreciate that.
But after playing this game some more, I realize that it is not so much the rate at which leaders die but more in what battles they fall. In particular, I loose a lot of leaders in battles without or with very few casualties on my side.
See for example this battle:
[ATTACH]13643[/ATTACH]
It is true a huge number of generals met their death during this conflict. Some in ways that feel almost "accidental" (misguided howitzer fire, etc.)
But come on the commanding admiral falls in a battle where the enemy didn't get a single shot off? Did he have a heart attack or did he slip over a water bucket and broke his neck???
Was it in the Ice March scenario ?Flop wrote:I sometimes lose generals, without any notice appearing. I've also seen generals just disappear, without even participating in a battle, and again, without any notice in log.
Cat Lord wrote:Was it in the Ice March scenario ?
Because the German advance relocate units, and sometimes they are far away from where they were, but have not been "lost".
Cat
After a battle a message in the message log will tell you if one of your leader was injured. In this case he will be removed from the stack, and lock in a city nearby for a certain number of turn, to recover from his injuries.Flop wrote:It was in the Grand Campaign. In my last turn, I was attacked at Ekaterinodar, where I had a force of ~50,000 men, led by Sorokin and Kalnin. I received a message that Kalnin was killed, but when I looked at the stack, Sorokin was gone, too.
Later in the same turn, I realised that the 2-star general, who starts out in Simbirsk (I don't remember his name), was gone, too. There was no battle in Simbirsk, though, and the stack was just standing there, doing nothing.
Flop wrote:It was in the Grand Campaign. In my last turn, I was attacked at Ekaterinodar, where I had a force of ~50,000 men, led by Sorokin and Kalnin. I received a message that Kalnin was killed, but when I looked at the stack, Sorokin was gone, too.
Later in the same turn, I realised that the 2-star general, who starts out in Simbirsk (I don't remember his name), was gone, too. There was no battle in Simbirsk, though, and the stack was just standing there, doing nothing.
Flop wrote:I've attached a zip with my current turn (the one I described above). At least, I think so. I have 4 Grand Campaign folders, so I've packed the highest numbered one. That should be the most recent one, right?
Included is the backup1 folder, as well as the files in the Grand Campaign3 folder, which I believe to be the current turn. Correct me if I'm wrong, and I'll upload the correct files.
Edit: It turns out that Sorokin disappeared several turns earlier, also without any battle taking place, and without any notice. The saves I've uploaded should still show the disappearance of Muraviev in Simbirsk, though.
Clovis wrote:OK. There's a event: "Muraviev executed" which has been fired this turn. So Muraviev removal is WAD. What's not is the absence of message. We will look at.
So it's not a bug. I will look at the data too to check if other leaders are suffering from other Revolutionary measures et give them the publicity they deserve for the edification of the masses
Flop wrote:Alright, that's good to know. Could that be the case with Sorokin, too? I can upload the saves from a few turns earlier, when he disappeared, if you want to look at them.
Flop wrote:These should be the saves, unless I miscounted.
Flop wrote:Are these events fixed or random? I don't suppose adding political commissars to a stack affects this?
Clovis wrote:They are fixed AND random. There 's a 10 % possibility both leaders to be executed each turn.
Adding political commissar have no influence about the outcome.
Flop wrote:Absolutely sure, at least with regard to Muraviev (I just checked). I didn't check Sorokin, since I'd have to revert to an earlier savegame, but I did check it earlier, before uploading that savegame, and I'm almost sure it didn't say anything about him being executed.
Mehring wrote:Bela Kun disappears
Mehring wrote:Bela Kun disappears
Return to “Help to improve RUS”
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 7 guests