During the attack on Compiegne, while using surprise and breakthrough, and also selecting a breakthrough to Paris.
Using 1.05
CTD during Attack on Compiegne w/Breakthrough
- Attachments
-
- Nov - Dec 1914.zip
- (431.33 KiB) Downloaded 230 times
calvinus wrote:I did exactly how you wrote... WEGO mode... no crash!
Mmmhh... have you disabled the "AI Logs" option (WW1 Configurator)?
Yes, I had disabled the AI logs.
Did you automatically execute the Compiegne battle (ie - check the little brain box in the lower lefthand corner)? I did that once and the computer committed all the reserves I was going to breakthrough attack Paris with. And I didn't have a CTD that time.
Really, you lost in Compiegne? I'm at work right now, but I recall the Compiegne battle as one in which the Germans had a large superiority (with a little "massive superiority" icon in the German battle box).
Maybe my battle crashed when the French AI tried to call up reserves.
Was your Compiegne battle a large one with both sides of the battle screen used? Mine wasn't. I'm not sure how you could have lost as, in my Compiegne battle, the Germans must have had 10 corps available (plus 5 in reserve, although one was the Austrian seige artillery).
Maybe a cause of the crash was that the German forces were from several different armies.
Maybe my battle crashed when the French AI tried to call up reserves.
Was your Compiegne battle a large one with both sides of the battle screen used? Mine wasn't. I'm not sure how you could have lost as, in my Compiegne battle, the Germans must have had 10 corps available (plus 5 in reserve, although one was the Austrian seige artillery).
Maybe a cause of the crash was that the German forces were from several different armies.
That's a problem resulting out of the fact that each time you load a savegame the AI starts a new move calculation again, so each time resulting in a different turn resolution.
Not sure how the AI move calculation is done, but if it is pseudo random based, it might help to store a seed to get reproducible results. But that's obviously a veeeery long shot...
oke:
Not sure how the AI move calculation is done, but if it is pseudo random based, it might help to store a seed to get reproducible results. But that's obviously a veeeery long shot...
oke:WhoCares wrote:That's a problem resulting out of the fact that each time you load a savegame the AI starts a new move calculation again, so each time resulting in a different turn resolution.
Not sure how the AI move calculation is done, but if it is pseudo random based, it might help to store a seed to get reproducible results. But that's obviously a veeeery long shot...
Randomic effects are surely present, but AI is not random of course!
I fear it is not that simple.
Usually you will get saves from the end of the phase when the player has finished his inputs, placed its replacements, probably played some events, ... However, the AI might have done its planning before the player had taken his actions, of which some (e.g. placing of reinforcements) might influence the AI decision path, others maybe trigger 'random-influenced' options (playing events like additional munition of which the actual number received is random). In this case, a restart from this save at the end of the turn will most likely still not result in the same AI movements as it did the first time.
However, it should be reproducible between multiple restarts.
I didn't want to imply that the AI just makes some random moves.
Usually you will get saves from the end of the phase when the player has finished his inputs, placed its replacements, probably played some events, ... However, the AI might have done its planning before the player had taken his actions, of which some (e.g. placing of reinforcements) might influence the AI decision path, others maybe trigger 'random-influenced' options (playing events like additional munition of which the actual number received is random). In this case, a restart from this save at the end of the turn will most likely still not result in the same AI movements as it did the first time.
However, it should be reproducible between multiple restarts.
calvinus wrote:Randomic effects are surely present, but AI is not random of course!
I didn't want to imply that the AI just makes some random moves.
Return to “WW1 Technical support / Aide technique”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests