Tue Jul 08, 2008 4:46 pm
I've played games like MTW, BFME and also play LOTRO now and again. One thing that always turns me off is the lack of realism. And I don't mean the graphics.
I hate it that Medieval Total War seems a bit like Medieval Europe - but it is not Medieval Europe! Names of Kings, regions, sometime countries, are made up.
The tactical level is interesting but is only really for "kids" who want to prove they are faster at moving their troops around then the other player. IMHO.
One example I could give you is the Longbow. Now in reality the longbow was a long-range and fast weapon (in trained hands). In MTW you are lucky if your Retenu bowmen can get 3 or 4 shots off before being run-down by french cavalry. Most battles in MTW2 last about 10 minutes. Not realistic and ultimately a waste of time.
I thought I would give Napoleon's Campaigns a go since I am looking for historical accuracy.
More detail and more tactical options would be great - but please don't go down the MTW2 road!