FM WarB wrote:As the number of men per element is mere flavor, the army totals you see are meaningless. Does this also mean that the battle computations are inaccurate?
Adlertag wrote:Besides number of men per element, reproducing almost historically the number of casualties in battle is one of the hardest task for the game engine.
FM WarB wrote:As the number of men per element is mere flavor, the army totals you see are meaningless. Does this also mean that the battle computations are inaccurate?
jastaV wrote:Looking at Model DB, with its complexity, we cannot argue "number of men per element is mere flavor": if so we could have very few models rather than the hundreds have been edited.
When then going to Units DB and how units are edited in setup files, I guess AGEod is doing anything to reproduce historically accurate OOBs.
Indeed, men per element in Models is just one of dozeens of factors to consider: cohesion, morale, but number of men are then important to computate battle results beeing most of losses not casualties but troops disbanded, fleeing out of ranks and so on.
FM WarB wrote:In devising oobs, if you are assigning elements to a "regiment" what are these elements? Are they companies, two companies per element or half companies? If the number of men per element is flavor, who knows?
As there are differing numbers of companies per regiment across the WiA, NCP, ACW era, and these companies have differing authorized strength, my question remains: what is "flavor," and how are battle correctly computed?
FM WarB wrote:In devising oobs, if you are assigning elements to a "regiment" what are these elements? Are they companies, two companies per element or half companies? If the number of men per element is flavor, who knows?
As there are differing numbers of companies per regiment across the WiA, NCP, ACW era, and these companies have differing authorized strength, my question remains: what is "flavor," and how are battle correctly computed?
Return to “Napoleon's Campaigns”
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 10 guests