enf91 wrote:Currently, NYC and Philly are worth 2 or 3 NM points upon their capture. Let's be realistic here. If the South had managed to capture either of those cities, especially New York, Northern support for the war would have evaporated. So here's my pitch: give the Northern player a MUCH bigger penalty for losing major cities. Just for realism. I think that even if the North had taken Richmond, if a Confederate army were in Philadelphia or New York, the North would have acceded to Southern demands.
W.Barksdale wrote:Yankees are a stubborn bunch...Even with with capture of a large city I'm sure they would continue to fight on if they could.
I like the FI idea, however, IMO the FI was not very well thought out. They British and American command systems get meshed so that British Generals are irate about American promotions etc.
The worse thing about FI is that the British divisions count towards the rebel division cap. Any of your promotable generals in charge of divisions will need to stay in charge that division lest you want to lose it for good!
I can definately see a big boost to FI, historically speaking, if the south had captured a large Federal city. However, I wouldn't want to see it put into the game until the underthought and undertested FI system is tweaked a wee bit.
Unfortunately, we probably won't see any major rework done if\when we see an AACW2.
slimey.rock wrote:I pretty much agree with all the above posters. If the South had pushed up as far as New York or maybe even Philidelphia, they could have bartered those conqueured territories off to the North in exchange for peace.
I also agree that any significan invasion from the South could have turned the war into "The war of Southern aggresion" instead of vice versa. Pushing the Northerners to fight that much harder.
The point is, though, that capturing major cities like Cincinatti, Chicago, Detroit; while significant economically, have no effect on morale.
Return to “Help to improve AACW!”
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 6 guests