AGEOD Forums

Captain

Hear, hear! I almost forgot thanks for your reference to FY. Prviously I thought it was just a Mod (which usually I don't go in for). I did not realize it was quizessential to playing the game. Thanks for enlightening me. I have spread the word and 'all' of my gaming associates have jumped the ship...

Captain

What facts? About history I have far more confidence in vanilia RUS, even I may prefer some treatment of FY. I have neither the time nor inclination to get into thumb tacks and pin counting. Healthy historical debate is welcome in historical academia, however that must always be tempered with histo...

Captain

The answer is obvious FY is an historical game simulation RUS is an abstract I don't know what.
Time it was fixed!

Captain

To put this in the most basic terms possible. FY should be the official game! The official game bares little semblence to historical fact. If it wasn't for FY my copy of RUS would already be in the bin which is a great tragedy as it has the potential to be a great game, one of Aegod's best. Now I am...

Captain

Yea I was the poor bloody victim. Ok Sorta and I are playing FY (thank god the offical game is so ahistorical you might as well name it after a Segio Leoneo spagetti western). Anyway kudos to Clovis FY is the game RUS should have been. Having said that Trotsky has just lost is 25000 main army to wra...

Captain

Glad I started an healthy and robust debate. Lots of good ideas, especially from Mexican and Narwhal :thumbsup: So far you blokes have concentrated on the eco/production side (which is a major fault) for me the glaring weakness is in the Dip game unable to reflect historical accuracy. TOC runs rings...

Captain

Does the red airforce reinf option work? Now I know it should only kick in once every 6 months but I seem to get reinfs only once. We are not in late 1919. Each time I have ensured I have left the correct WSU, ma, money etc. Now if it is before the 6 months why does the option present itself? Surely...

Captain

Obviously the bourgeoise have their spies openly walking about the Kremlin delivering dispatches to Kolchak on a daily basis.
So it that it?
The game is meant to be like that?
Pray tell what historical basis is there for that?
Please tell me its player error or a bug.

Captain

Another suggestion is what TOC did. TOC added the third player as Poland (which historically in terms of influence and military might is absolutely correct). Now the white split as is seems ok but what about options for other players as Poland, Ukraine and Finland? Also the other minors should follo...

Captain

Now depite my posts heading I think this is a great game. Given that caveat it behooves all of us to push for the best possible product avaliable, i.e. a simulation that reflects historical reality but balanced by the fact that 'some' players may be brilliant enough or have a poor enough oponent to ...

Captain

Now quite possibly it is my inferior play as the Reds, but having played around 6 times vs players and AI (and being a very seasoned AACW player) I am continually having difficulty comining anywhere near replicating the historical success of the Reds. Now I have some observations but prefer to hang ...

Captain

Now am I doing something stupid or are the Reds intentionally not meant to see White vps and NM. In several campaign games I can only view Anarchists, Ukrainians, Poles and Germans, not particularly useful you must agree. On the other hand my white adversaries know all about me on their respective o...

Captain

We are playing the full campaign.
I activated the Anarchists 2 turns ago but can still only see Grigorev's force and can move none at all?

Captain

That's right as the Reds I could only see the western Anarchists near Odessa.
You may have to go back 2 turns

Captain

Any good samaritans out there? I am the Reds getting hammered and now to add insult to injury the Anarchists deuct my morale costs but don't join the fight!
Now where's a good game techo when you need one

Captain

NY Rangers wrote:Yes I have. My guess is that 100% military control and some treshold value of loyalty is needed first.

Good to know I will be on trying

Captain

my last log file: 21:21:20 [Error ] TRegionDefs.GetRegionsList FullDebug: Num of iters equals 15 This is too high to be safe 21:21:20 [Error ] TRegionDefs.GetRegionsList FullDebug: Num of iters equals 15 This is too high to be safe 21:21:20 [Error ] TRegionDefs.GetRegionsList FullDebug: Num of iter...

Captain

NY Rangers wrote:Region loyalty might be a factor though...

Out of interest has anyone successfully built a fort other than thru the various option?

Captain

Red air force and prisoners worked once now don't work

. Red generals no worries

Don't know about party members?

Captain

I would also like to know where on egets this fixed or patched?

Captain

ok 3 successive campaign games and Trotsky dies early in each one. This does not happen with any other leader.
Does anyone else have this problem?
Is related to his special train ability?
Next time I will save the game and upload, just wanted to know if anyone else had this problem/

Captain

Thanks Seb :) There is an icon to build a fort for every unit without artilery and a message after the turn fort complete . But no forts are built luckly ;) just message error maybe. Same with single supply wagon unit that can build a depot with an icon but no depot after turn. Yes I have the same ...

Captain

Besides the benefit that Gray has said, when you merge two militia units (two elements in a unit) you can reduce to one command points, what is very important, especially until you can form divisions. Merging is utilising the same principle except on location ;-) I often accompany divisions, corps ...

Captain

Use the replacement system. It's what it is specifically designed for. It removes the burdensome micromanagement that you are doing. The only real use for merging is to speed up the production of 2 element militia units since the number of 1 element militia units is limited to a finite number allow...

Captain

You do know that you can go directly to the leader's location from the roster by clicking on the star(s) graphic to the right of the name in the roster? The roster also states what region the leader is located in (just below his name) Of course but their is no listing if the leader is dead! It is m...

Captain

[quote="Pocus"]That would be a bug, if the corps don't come back just after battle in his original position. I guess I'll need a save (with backup1) to check this one. Yes I had the same problem. Caught all my Corps from the army out of position as I thought they were where they were befor...

Captain

Ok just looked on the roster.Watie, Morgan and Bee are all grahiclly 2 star generals on the board in my game. On the roster it says Rank 2 fro all 3. However the graphic star in box on the roster only displays a one star. Morgan and Bee I had no problem giving Corps to. Watie the program just wouldn...

Captain

Thanks Pat, yes I knew that about non-divisonal commanders surviving. You have obviously learnt to play around this one

However it really isn't a very realistic solution.
That leader roster same as the unit roster for missing elements would be soooo helpful.

Captain

Jim-re naming the army you are quite possibly right on that one. Gray-Recently I stacked Watie with Bee's Corp and guess what? Bee lost his Corp and Watie became a Corp Commander (despite the numerous times I tried to do this the program would not accept Watie as a Corp commander). I canm upload the...

Captain

Jim, admittedly my statehood passion is not critical and essentially superflous. However the ability to see what elements a brigade is missing and therefore able to merge the correct units is a major game aid indeed. To be able to see this at a glance on a roster would save enormous labour for playe...

Search found 169 matches

To NY Ranger

Make FY the official game!

Kudos to FY

Trotsky bug

Thanks fellas

Red Air Force

Lack of Intelligence

Play Balance

What's the point in playing an unrealistic game?

Who wins the most?

Objectives page

Anarchists

Anarchists

Help

Forts

Me too

Fort construction

Me too!

Me too!

Trotsky keeps dying

forts and Redoubts

Me Too

Narrowing Bug down

Gamey Solution

Watie's Promotion catches up

Labor Intensive?